Skip to main content

Taking Every Thought Captive:

Forty Years of Christian Scholar’s Review

Edited by David A. Hoekema, Don W. King, Perry L. Glanzer, Jerry Pattengale, Todd C. Ream, Todd Steen


Hardcover: 384 pages
Publisher: Abilene Christian University Press
Publish Date: May 16, 2011
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0891125477
ISBN-13: 978-0891125471

While the search for meaning and purpose appears to be a constant throughout human history, there are characteristics about our current time period that make this search different from any other previous time, particularly for college students. In this book, Perry L. Glanzer, Jonathan P. Hill, and Byron R. Johnson explore college students’ search for meaning and purpose and the role that higher education plays. To shed empirical light on this complex issue, the authors draw on in-depth interviews with four hundred college students from different types of institutions across the United States. They also analyze three sets of national survey data: the National Study of Youth and Religion, College Students Beliefs and Values, and their own Gallup-conducted survey of 2,500 college students. Their research identifies important social, educational, and cultural influences that shape students’ quests and the answers they find. Arguing against a utilitarian view of education, Glanzer, Hill, and Johnson conclude that colleges and universities can and should cultivate and aid students in their journeys, and they offer suggestions for doing so.


Perry L. Glanzer is Professor of Educational Foundations at Baylor University and a Resident Scholar with the Baylor Institute for Studies of Religion. His books include Restoring the Soul of the University: Unifying Christian Higher Education in a Fragmented Age (coauthored with Nathan F. Alleman and Todd C. Ream).

Jonathan P. Hill is Associate Professor of Sociology at Calvin College and the coauthor (with Christian Smith, Kyle Longest, and Kari Christoffersen) of Young Catholic America: Emerging Adults In, Out of, and Gone from the Church.

Byron R. Johnson is Distinguished Professor of the Social Sciences at Baylor University and the author of More God, Less Crime: Why Faith Matters and How It Could Matter More.


An invaluable compendium of classic essays on Christian higher education and scholarship, Taking Every Thought Captive brings together a veritable who’s who in Christian academic thought. Both new faculty and seasoned veterans alike will find this volume an excellent resource for thinking about and discussing the role of the Christian scholar today.

— Susan VanZanten
Professor of English, Seattle Pacific University

For four decades the Christian Scholar’s Review has led the way in encouraging Christian thinking about how to love and serve God intellectually. This book offers some of the best writing and thinking that the journal has produced.

— Joel A. Carpenter
Director of the Nagel Institute for the Study of World Christianity,
Calvin University

Table of Contents

List of Illustrations
Introduction Searching for Meaning and Purpose in College: A Dying Quest?

Part I: The Context of the Quest

1. Are Colleges Giving Up on Life’s Meaning and Purpose? The Historical and Cultural Context

2. The Adolescent Journey: The Precollege Path to Finding Meaning and Purpose

3. Mapping the Presence of Purpose: How Identity, Social Context, and Education Matter

Part II. Figuring Out College Students’ Quest

4. Developing Purpose in the Contemporary University: Four Stories

5. Mapping What Makes Life Meaningful

6. The Diverse Purposes of College Students

7. Is Purposelessness a Problem?

Part III. Questing in the University

8. Encountering Purpose in the Classroom

9. Looking for Purpose Outside of Class

Part IV. The Heart, Hope, and Soul of Purpose

10. Purpose with Soul: The Religious

11. Finding Purpose in a Universe without One: The Nontheists

12. How Does the Story End? Purpose, the Good Life, and the Future


Appendix A: Methods
Appendix B: Interview Guide: 110 Students at 10 Campuses
Appendix C: Statistical Supplement to Chapters 3 and 10